Manuscript Version | MPR decision (n = 25) | SPR decision (n = 30) | Editor decision | Editor agreed with MPR | Editor agreed with SPR |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Manuscript 1 R0 | Major | Minor | Major | yes | no |
Manuscript 1 R1 | Minor | Accept | Minor | yes | no |
Manuscript 2 R0 | Â | Major/Major | Major | Â | Â |
Manuscript 2 R1 | Minor | Major/Minor | Minor | Â | Â |
Manuscript 2 R2 | Â | Minor | Minor | Â | Â |
Manuscript 2 R3 | Â | Minor | Accept | Â | Â |
Manuscript 3 R0 | Major | Accept | Major | yes | no |
Manuscript 3 R1 | Accept | RR/Minor | Minor | no | yes |
Manuscript 3 R2 | RR | RR | RR | Â | Â |
Manuscript 4 R0 | Accept/Minor | Minor | Minor | Â | Â |
Manuscript 4 R1 | Accept | Accept | Accept | Â | Â |
Manuscript 5 R0 | Minor | Accept | Minor | yes | no |
Manuscript 5 R1 | Accept | Â | Accept | Â | Â |
Manuscript 6 R0 | Reject | Major | Reject | yes | no |
Manuscript 7 R0 | Reject | Accept/Minor | Minor | no | yes |
Manuscript 7 R1 | RR/RR | Accept/Minor | RR | yes | no |
Manuscript 8 R0 | Minor | Â | Minor | Â | Â |
Manuscript 8 R1 | Accept | Major | Minor | no | no |
Manuscript 9 R0 | Reject | Major/RR | Reject | yes | no |
Manuscript 10 R0 | Accept | Minor | Minor | no | yes |
Manuscript 11 R0 | Minor | Accept | Minor | yes | no |
Manuscript 12 R0 | Major | Major/Minor | Major | Â | Â |
Manuscript 12 R1 | RR | RR | RR | Â | Â |
Manuscript 13 R0 | Major/Major | Major | Major | Â | Â |
Manuscript 13 R1 | Accept | Minor | Accept | yes | no |